15000, Inc.

How to Get Maximum Cooling from your Swamp Cooler

My wife, Linda, and I have a cabin in a hot, dry, little town no one has ever heard of – Groveland, California. Summertime temperatures regularly reach above the 100 degree mark. The cabin came with a rooftop evaporative cooler, AKA “swamp cooler”. The unit seemed to provide some cooling until the outside air temperature reaches over 95 degrees. At that point it seems to blow nothing but hot air, not unlike the author.

IMG_20140706_123237_770

The Swamp Cooler on the Cabin Roof

Linda was getting quite frustrated with the uncomfortable conditions in the cabin. Although she didn’t verbalize as much, I could see her brain thinking, “Why the hell did I marry a guy who designs HVAC systems for a living? This dork can’t even figure out how to cool our tiny cabin!”

After a few days of sweating like a dog (no offense Bandit!) I decided to go “all-engineer” on it. Whipping out my portable calculator/telecommunication device/inter-web searcher, I began to research the problem.

One southern gentleman suggested the problem could be inadequate water flow. He had added a second spray pump and doubled the distribution nozzles to each media bank. “Now this sounds like a real engineered solution”, I thought! I was ready to run to the hardware store and spend a hundred dollars on supplies to turbo-charge my swamp cooler.

Fortunately I did a little more research.

There were quite a number of good-ole-boys who were suggesting a much simpler solution. The recommendation was to get rid of the high-tech, multi-season, blue foam media and install two thicknesses of the old style “Aspen” media. This is the media that looks like curly straw – and is cheaper than the new and improved blue foam media ($4 vs almost $6).

IMG_20140706_085225_991

The Blue Foam Media – Note the wetted areas are clean and the dry areas are dirty. Dry areas mean no evaporation is taking place which reduces efficiency.

Aspen-Pad-Large

The Aspen Pad – Absorbs Water which increases it’s efficiency. Although you have to change them every year the performance difference is so great it is worth the effort and cost

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Since this was a cheaper, easier, solution than installing a new pumping system I decided to give it a try.

I recorded before and after temperature data to analyze any improvements from the new media. With the blue foam media still in place, I recorded the following data:

Outside air temp. at the roof                                       = 95 deg. F.

Supply air temp. at the evap. cooler outlet          = 84 deg. F.

Temp. difference from evap. cooler (95 – 84)     = 11 deg. F.

Room temp. (extremely uncomfortable!)             = 89 deg. F.

IMG_20140706_123936_114

The temperature at the roof – 95 deg. F.

I made a quick run to the Lowes store in Sonora and found the Aspen media available in many sizes.

Back at home, on the cabin roof, I found it was quite easy to fit two thicknesses of the Aspen media into the swamp cooler panel frame. It took only 15 minutes to install the eight panels of media onto the four sides.

I let the pump run without the fan for about 10 minutes to let the media get fully wet. In the meantime I again used a digital thermometer to take measurements of the temperature at the roof and the room temperate. I then stuck the digital thermometer into the supply air outlet of the swamp cooler and turned the fan and pump on high.

The results were stunning!

Outside air temp. at the roof                                       = 95 deg. F.

Supply air temp. at the evap. cooler outlet         = 62 deg. F.

Temp. difference from evap. cooler (96 – 62)     = 33 deg. F.

Room temp. after two hours                                          = 75 deg. F.

IMG_20140706_124619_477

The digital thermometer in the supply grille from the evaporative cooler – a frigid 62 degrees!

The old-school Aspen media resulted in a whopping 33 degree temp difference between the incoming outside air and the room supply air. The “new and improved” blue foam media could only achieve a 11 degree temperature difference.

In an era when rapid change has become a normal part of our lives, it is somewhat comforting to find the “old” way is, sometimes, still the best way.

My wife Linda was more than a little impressed with my inexpensive solution to the problem. It is good to remind her that, as annoying as my “engineer attitude” can be, every once in a while there is some benefit to having married a dork.

Gary Welch

About the Author
Gary Welch is a principal of 15000 Inc. with over 40 years experience in the field of HVAC, plumbing and fire protection design. He can be reached at gary@15000inc.com.
  1. Jay Takacs

    Reminds me of the apple sauce experiment! Lol…